Some manufactures of Tubular cells claim that having more membrane area versus anode area is important and critical. However there is no mention or calculations in electro deposition that this applies too.
E-Coat is dependant on Anode Area with respect to anolyte cells. Extra membrane does not have any benefit electrically. Thus, if you are looking to run efficiently and use what you pay for ThinCells will do the trick.
Tube cell technology is 35+ years old. ThinCells are state of the art technology, for todays applications higher load demands.